Long Island's dining scene combines the freshest local ingredients with world-class culinary expertise. From farm-to-table establishments to sophisticated fine dining, these top three restaurants showcase the best of Long Island's gastronomic offerings.
Quick Guide to Long Island Dining
- Best Seasons: Summer for fresh seafood, Fall for harvest menus
- Price Range: $75-$200 per person
- Reservation Tips: Book 2-4 weeks ahead for peak seasons
- Wine Regions: North Fork vineyards pair perfectly with local cuisine
- Dress Code: Smart casual to formal
North Fork Table & Inn (Southold)
Restaurant Overview
- Location: 57225 Main Road, Southold
- Style: Contemporary American Farm-to-Table
- Price Range: $85-200 per person
- James Beard Recognition: Multiple nominations
Dining Experience
-
Menu Highlights
- Seasonal tasting menu ($125)
- À la carte options
- Local wine pairings
- Vegetarian options
-
Signature Dishes
- Long Island Duck
- Local Oyster Selection
- House-made Pasta
- Seasonal Desserts
What Makes It Special
-
Farm Partnerships
- Daily harvested produce
- Local seafood
- Artisanal cheese selections
-
Atmosphere
- Historic inn setting
- Elegant dining rooms
- Seasonal outdoor seating
Best Times to Visit
- Lunch: Thursday-Sunday
- Dinner: Wednesday-Sunday
- Peak Season: May-October
For more information: North Fork Table & Inn Website
Jewel Restaurant (Melville)
Restaurant Details
- Location: 400 Broadhollow Road, Melville
- Style: Contemporary American
- Setting: Modern elegance
- Perfect For: Business dining, special occasions
-
Dinner Options
- Prix Fixe ($75)
- Chef's Tasting ($95)
- Extensive wine list
-
Popular Dishes
- Aged Prime Steaks
- Fresh Seafood Tower
- Handmade Pastas
- Seasonal Specialties
Special Features
-
Private Dining
- Multiple rooms available
- Custom menus
- Corporate events
-
Wine Program
- 500+ selections
- Local and international wines
- Expert sommelier service
Insider Tips
- Reserve window seats
- Try the bar menu for casual dining
- Check seasonal specials
- Sunday brunch is popular
For details: Jewel Restaurant Information
Mirabelle Restaurant & Tavern
Restaurant Overview
- Location: 150 Main Street, Stony Brook
- Chef: Guy Reuge
- Style: French-inspired American
- Setting: Historic Three Village Inn
Dining Options
-
Main Restaurant
- Prix Fixe ($85)
- Seasonal tasting menus
- French classics
-
Tavern Experience
- Casual atmosphere
- À la carte menu
- Craft cocktails
Signature Dishes
-
French Classics
- Duck à l'Orange
- Bouillabaisse
- Soufflés
- House-made Pâtés
-
Local Specialties
- Long Island Wine Country Chicken
- North Fork Vegetables
- Local Seafood Selection
Special Events
-
Wine Dinners
- Monthly events
- Local winery partnerships
- Limited seating
-
Holiday Celebrations
- Special menus
- Festive atmosphere
- Early booking essential
For reservations: Mirabelle Official Website
Tips for Dining in Long Island
Making the Most of Your Visit
-
Seasonal Considerations
- Summer: Fresh seafood focus
- Fall: Harvest menus
- Winter: Hearty French classics
- Spring: Local produce
-
Transportation Tips
- Valet parking available
- Car service recommended for wine tastings
- Consider staying at associated inns
Special Occasions
-
Private Events
- Custom menus available
- Room buyouts possible
- Special decoration options
-
Celebrations
- Birthday arrangements
- Anniversary specials
- Group dining options
Wine Country Connections
- Visit local vineyards before dinner
- Ask about wine pairing events
- Join wine clubs for special access
Budget-Friendly Options
- Money-Saving Tips
- Lunch service offers better value
- Early bird specials
- Restaurant week participation
- Bar menus
Local's Tip: These restaurants represent the best of Long Island's diverse culinary scene. Each offers a unique experience combining local ingredients with expert preparation. For the best experience, consider visiting during shoulder season (April-May or September-October) when crowds are smaller but seasonal ingredients are still abundant.
Thanks for visiting! 🍽️
Love from ICityTravel 🧡
Last Updated: February 2024 - All information verified directly with restaurants
